How to Invest in Real Estate with a Self-Directed IRA

Read Time: 8 min

Category:

Multifamily

Most accredited investors know their IRA or 401(k) can hold stocks, bonds, and mutual funds. Fewer realize the IRS permits these accounts to hold real estate, private placements, and syndication investments, provided the account is held at a custodian that allows alternative assets. A self-directed IRA is not a special account type under IRS rules. It is a traditional or Roth IRA where the account holder, rather than a brokerage, directs the investment decisions. For high-income investors who have already maxed out conventional returns in public markets, this opens a genuinely different alternative.

What Is a Self-Directed IRA?

A self-directed IRA (SDIRA) operates under the same IRS rules as a conventional IRA, including contribution limits, distribution rules, and tax treatment. The difference is the custodian. Standard brokerages restrict IRA investments to publicly traded securities. SDIRA custodians allow account holders to direct capital into a broader range of assets, including private placement real estate, multifamily syndications, promissory notes, and more. The IRS does not restrict what an IRA can invest in; the custodian does. Choosing a custodian that permits real estate investments is the first practical step.

Traditional vs. Roth SDIRA for Real Estate

Both traditional and Roth SDIRAs can hold real estate syndication interests. With a traditional SDIRA, contributions may be tax-deductible, and gains compound tax-deferred until withdrawal in retirement. With a Roth SDIRA, contributions are made with after-tax dollars, but qualified distributions in retirement are tax-free, including gains from real estate held inside the account. For investors who expect to generate strong appreciation over a long time horizon, the Roth structure can be advantageous. The right choice depends on your current tax bracket, expected future tax rates, and investment timeline. Your tax advisor is the right person to model the comparison.

Setting Up an SDIRA for Real Estate Investments

Choosing a Custodian

Not all SDIRA custodians are the same. Look for a custodian with experience handling private placements, a clear fee schedule, and a track record of processing alternative investment transactions efficiently. Processing delays at the custodian level can affect your ability to fund a syndication before a capital call deadline. Common SDIRA custodians in this space include Equity Trust, Millennium Trust, and others who specialize in self-directed accounts. Evaluate current options and their fee structures independently before making a selection.

Funding the Account

You can fund an SDIRA through an annual contribution (subject to IRS limits), a direct rollover from a prior employer's 401(k), or a transfer from an existing IRA. Rolling over a substantial balance from a former employer plan is one of the most common ways investors seed a new SDIRA with enough capital to participate in a syndication at minimum investment thresholds. Transfers are generally tax-free when handled correctly, but the mechanics matter. Work with the custodian and your tax advisor to make sure the rollover is structured as a direct rollover rather than a distribution.

Making the Investment

Once your SDIRA is funded and you have selected a syndication, you instruct the custodian to wire funds to the investment on behalf of the IRA. All documents, including the subscription agreement, must be executed in the name of the IRA, not in your personal name. For example: "Equity Trust Company FBO [Your Name] IRA." All returns, quarterly distributions, and exit proceeds flow back into the IRA account. You cannot redirect distributions to a personal bank account without triggering a prohibited transaction.

Tax Considerations Inside an SDIRA

Unrelated Business Taxable Income (UBIT)

The most important tax consideration for IRA investors in real estate is UBIT: Unrelated Business Taxable Income. When an IRA uses debt-financed property to generate income, a portion of that income becomes taxable at the trust tax rate, even inside the IRA. This applies to most standard multifamily syndications because deals use mortgage debt. UBIT does not eliminate the benefit of investing through an SDIRA, but it reduces it. The taxable portion of income is calculated based on the ratio of debt to the property's adjusted basis, which is called the debt-financed income ratio. Consult a tax advisor experienced with SDIRA real estate to model the net impact before committing capital.

Prohibited Transactions

The IRS prohibits certain transactions between an IRA and disqualified persons, which include the account holder, their spouse, direct descendants, and certain affiliated business entities. For real estate syndications, this matters if you or a disqualified person have an ownership or management interest in the GP entity. A prohibited transaction can disqualify the entire IRA, triggering immediate taxes and penalties on the full account balance. Review any investment carefully with your custodian and tax advisor if you have any affiliation with the sponsor before submitting a subscription.

Investing in Multifamily Syndications Through an SDIRA

FeatureStandard Brokerage IRASelf-Directed IRA
Asset types allowedStocks, bonds, mutual fundsStocks, private placements, real estate
Real estate syndicationsNot permittedPermitted
Tax treatment on gainsTax-deferred or tax-free (Roth)Tax-deferred or tax-free (Roth)
UBIT applicabilityRareCommon with leveraged real estate
Custodian optionsAny major brokerageSpecialized custodians only

How the Process Works with Red Brick Equity

Red Brick Equity accepts SDIRA capital in its syndications. When investing through an SDIRA, you will need to provide your custodian's wiring instructions and have the subscription documents executed in the name of your IRA. RBE's investor portal handles the administrative process, and the team coordinates with SDIRA custodians to meet funding deadlines. The minimum investment is the same as for personal capital, currently $25,000 per deal (subject to change by deal), regardless of whether you invest through a tax-advantaged account or personally. Accredited investor verification through RBE uses a third-party service paid for by RBE, at no cost to you, and can be completed through the investor portal.

Time Horizon and Liquidity Considerations

Syndication investments are illiquid, typically for a 3-to-7-year hold period. This makes them well-suited for IRAs, where the intention is long-term capital accumulation rather than near-term liquidity. Unlike a publicly traded REIT you can sell tomorrow, a syndication interest cannot be redeemed early outside of the GP's discretion. Match the investment's expected hold period to your anticipated need for those IRA funds. For investors who are 20-plus years from retirement, illiquidity is a minor constraint relative to the tax-advantaged compounding potential.

Investment VehicleLiquidityTypical HoldUBIT Exposure
Multifamily syndicationIlliquid4-7 yearsYes (typically)
Public REITDaily liquidityN/APossible
Delaware Statutory TrustIlliquid5-10 yearsYes
Private real estate fundIlliquid5-10 yearsPossible

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I use a 401(k) to invest in a real estate syndication?

Standard employer-sponsored 401(k) plans do not allow private real estate investments. However, if you have left an employer and the plan allows rollovers, you can roll those funds into an SDIRA and then invest in syndications. Some self-employed investors also use a Solo 401(k), which can hold alternative assets and offers higher annual contribution limits than a standard IRA. Each structure has its own rules and UBIT implications.

Is a self-directed IRA safe?

The SDIRA structure is legal and IRS-sanctioned. The risk lies in the investment itself, not the account structure. All the same due diligence you would apply when investing personal capital, sponsor track record, market selection, deal-level underwriting conservatism, should apply when evaluating an SDIRA investment. The tax-advantaged wrapper does not change the underlying risk of the asset.

Do distributions from a syndication go into the IRA?

Yes. All distributions, including quarterly operating distributions and exit proceeds, must return to the IRA. Directing a distribution to a personal account while the investment is held inside your IRA is a prohibited transaction with serious tax consequences. The custodian handles receiving proceeds and crediting them to your account.

Can I invest with Red Brick Equity through an SDIRA?

Yes. Red Brick Equity accepts SDIRA capital and has worked with investors using various custodians. Contact RBE's investor relations team for guidance on the subscription process. The team can coordinate with your custodian to ensure documents are executed correctly and funding arrives on schedule.

What is the minimum investment if I am using an SDIRA?

The minimum investment is the same as for personal capital, currently $25,000 per deal and subject to variation by deal. Ensure your SDIRA has enough liquid capital to meet the minimum, cover any UBIT obligations if applicable, and maintain a reserve for future capital calls if the deal structure includes them. Do not drain your SDIRA to the minimum without headroom for contingencies.

Tags

Multifamily